The standard FRP cable tray is generally suited to applications with regular cable routing requirements and available sizes, whereas custom FRP cable tray works well for projects needing a particular size of width, height, length, fitment or configuration. The selection of the right option is based on cable load, installation conditions, corrosive environment, available space, specification of the project and overall cost of the installation.
For chemical plants, factories, substations, sewage treatment plants and other industrial applications, it becomes very necessary to choose the appropriate cable tray for organizing the cables.
Fiberglass Reinforced Plastic (FRP) cable trays are usually selected for the installations where corrosion resistance, light weight and non-conducting property of cables is of primary concern. But should you go for a standard tray or customize one?
Here we make a comparison between the two for helping you make an informed decision.
The standard FRP cable trays come in pre-existing sizes and shapes. These cable trays can be used when the cable placement, installation, and load requirements coincide with the specifications provided by the manufacturer.
Some of the common examples of standard FRP cable trays are as follows:
Channel type FRP cable trays – used for certain cable runs and places where a narrow size of cable tray is preferred.
Ladder type FRP cable trays – usually preferred for large-scale cable runs where an open structure design is required.
Ventilated FRP cable trays – offered by some manufacturers for applications that need extra cable support and ventilation.
There may be various sizes and resin systems available from the standard FRP cable trays of each manufacturer.
Chemical processing environments can expose flooring systems to acids, alkalis, moisture, chemical vapours and cleaning solutions. Conventional steel grating may require corrosion protection and ongoing maintenance, depending on its environment.
FRP grating can be a suitable option when its material properties match the operating conditions.
If the size is already available or can be manufactured using an existing manufacturing procedure, then this could quicken the procurement process, depending on the availability of stock and manufacturing procedures.
Established sizes and layouts enable the manufacturer to give quotes without having to go through extensive design discussions. This makes budgeting and comparisons easy at the initial stage.
If the existing sizes coincide with the cable routing plans that have been approved, then this will ease the installation process.
The use of standard trays is ideal in cases where there are uniform specifications required in many buildings or production areas along different routes.
The use of one particular size makes it easier to plan for future additions or replacements, assuming the size specification is still available.
Standard trays might not be ideal where the project has:
Where this is the case, using a standard tray will only cause further fabrication and installation problems.
Custom FRP cable trays are made or customized to suit the particular needs of the project. The customization could be in the form of dimensions, lengths, profile of the tray, choice of resins, fittings, mounting, or any other design feature.
They are usually specified in difficult industrial applications where off-the-shelf products cannot properly fit the approved design or operating conditions.
Depending on the abilities of the manufacturer, custom FRP cable trays may have:
Note: Customization has to stay within the capabilities of the manufacturer. The dimension, spacing of supports, loading capacity, and the material have to be verified with respect to the project requirement.
Trays can be tailored around columns, mechanical equipment, pipework, structural elements of the building, and tight space constraints. Such an approach can minimize the need for on-site adjustments.
When the required layout of cable trays does not suit any of the standard sizes from the manufacturer, custom trays can prove more convenient.
Industrial conditions can lead to moisture, chemical corrosion, exposure to sun, high temperatures, or other factors which can affect the material used for cable trays. In this case, custom production can allow specifying certain resin system or other properties of the material according to the environment.
The chemical resistance needs to be checked against real conditions of exposure to the chemicals, their concentration, temperatures, and so on.
Special curves, tees, reducers, transitions, and other fittings are required in complex cable routings. Their planning together with the tray system can facilitate the installation process.
In case when the installation is well-planned prior to production, custom trays can help avoid on-site cutting, drilling, and other modifications. It all depends on how accurate the drawings and measurements are.
There are also factors involved with custom solutions:
Increased need for design approval: Mistakes in dimensions or assumptions could be costly to fix.
Custom trays work best when all of their requirements are determined in advance.
| Comparison Factor | Standard FRP Cable Trays | Custom FRP Cable Trays |
|---|---|---|
| Dimensions | Available in established sizes | Manufactured or configured to agreed dimensions |
| Initial cost | Often more economical for conventional requirements | May cost more due to specialised requirements |
| Lead time | May be shorter if available or part of regular production | May require additional design and manufacturing time |
| Design flexibility | Limited to available configurations | Greater flexibility within manufacturing capabilities |
| Cable routing | Suitable for conventional layouts | Useful for complex or restricted layouts |
| Fittings | Uses available standard fittings | Special fittings may be specified |
| Material selection | Based on available product specifications | Can allow application-specific material requirements |
| Installation | Straightforward when dimensions match the layout | Can reduce site modifications when accurately designed |
| Repeat projects | Suitable for recurring standard requirements | Suitable when repeat projects need the same specialised design |
| Best suited for | Conventional cable routes and routine installations | Complex layouts and project-specific requirements |
The best choice is not always the cheapest tray per metre. Consider the full project cost, including fittings, supports, transportation, installation labour, site modifications, and future maintenance.
Standard FRP cable trays would most likely be a better choice if there is certainty about the requirements of the project and the manufacturer is able to offer standard products that suit the specifications.
Use standard trays in case:
Cable paths that are fairly long and have simple turns and branches can do well with standard tray units and fittings.
In cases where the required width, sidewall height, and length are compatible with the available products, the added value from custom manufacturing may not be worth the additional expense.
Standard products can help you with your quotations, purchasing, and scheduling, especially if you are certain about the quantities and specifications required.
Standard parts may be suitable for factories, commercial and industrial sites where the cable paths are alike throughout the areas involved.
In cases where the available FRP material is suited for the environmental conditions, temperatures, climatic conditions, and performance requirements of the location, standard trays would do.
Standard FRP cable trays would most likely be a better choice if there is certainty about the requirements of the project and the manufacturer is able to offer standard products that suit the specifications.
Use standard trays in case:
Cable paths that are fairly long and have simple turns and branches can do well with standard tray units and fittings.
In cases where the required width, sidewall height, and length are compatible with the available products, the added value from custom manufacturing may not be worth the additional expense.
Standard products can help you with your quotations, purchasing, and scheduling, especially if you are certain about the quantities and specifications required.
Standard parts may be suitable for factories, commercial and industrial sites where the cable paths are alike throughout the areas involved.
In cases where the available FRP material is suited for the environmental conditions, temperatures, climatic conditions, and performance requirements of the location, standard trays would do.
Custom-made FRP cable trays should be considered in cases where the standard cable tray sizes/configurations do not meet the requirements of the particular project.
Industrial environments typically have existing piping, ductwork, steel framework, and machines. They will affect the space that is available for cable routing.
The use of a custom configuration may help in accommodating the available space while at the same time ensuring that there is sufficient access, separation of cables, and proper installation clearance.
The selection of cable tray dimensions should be made in relation to the number of cables to be routed, their size, the cable tray arrangement, filling requirements, the potential for expansion, and the project standards.
In cases where standard widths cannot accommodate the cable tray arrangement, a custom width may be considered.
However, just because the tray is wider does not mean that the load carrying capacity of the tray will be satisfactory. The loading characteristics, supports, spans, fittings, and loads have to be taken into consideration.
A chemical plant, wastewater plant, or an industrial installation may subject the trays to harsh chemicals, corrosion fumes, humidity, or exposure to the outdoor environment.
In case the standard resin system or construction of the product does not comply with your project, then you may need to consider custom manufacturing. Check with the manufacturer whether the materials are compatible with chemicals, temperatures, UV rays, and any other fire performance features required.
Some projects demand special dimensions, mechanical requirements, colour codes, documentation, and inspections. Custom manufacturing may work in such cases provided that the manufacturer complies with these specifications.
Example: In a chemical processing plant, the need for cable routing around the existing equipment and pipes may demand special tray dimensions and fumes from corrosive products. This calls for custom FRP cable tray systems.
The cost comparison will vary depending on the specific project rather than just based on whether the tray is a standard or custom item.
When the standard FRP cable trays have an appropriate size and fittings selection, then they can be cheaper to buy than their custom-made alternatives. Although custom trays can be more expensive per piece, they offer value when they avoid modifications to installation, mismatches of fittings, excess materials, and delay issues.
Prior to doing a quotation comparison, take into account these cost items:
Maintenance and life span: Assess the tray for compatibility with the actual environmental conditions rather than assume equal longevity for FRP trays.
Plastic Fabricators provides FRP cable trays for industrial use. In assessing the needs for cable trays, it is necessary to consult the manufacturer on the use, dimensions, loading, installation layout, and environmental conditions.
Depending on the project needs, the consultation may include:
Explore the FRP Cable Trays product page to review the available product range and discuss your project requirements.
In case you want to have a precise quote, provide necessary dimensions, quantity estimate, cable specifications, installation plans and environmental parameters. The manufacturer will be able to determine whether a standard design is applicable or custom design is needed.
The selection of standard or customized FRP cable tray systems is determined by the degree of compatibility between the existing range of products and the needs of the project.
Use standard FRP cable tray systems if the existing dimensional, fitting, materials, and loading criteria satisfy the installation criteria. They are easier to procure and provide excellent value for routine applications.
Opt for customized FRP cable tray systems if the project necessitates certain dimensional, fitting, routing, or material properties which cannot be satisfied by standard products.
However, prior to a conclusive decision, make a cost comparison, check the loading and supporting criteria, and confirm the suitability of the materials used.
For industrial projects in India, contact Plastic Fabricators through its FRP Cable Trays product to discuss your dimensions, quantities, installation layout, and technical requirements.
WhatsApp us