Skip to main content

Plastic Fabricators

PP Ducting vs FRP Ducting: Which Is Right for Your Application?

PP Ducting and FRP Ducting are extensively utilized in industries for industrial ventilation and chemical fume extraction applications. But then again, the best option would depend upon the kind of chemicals involved, operating temperature, mechanical demands, dimensions of the duct, and other factors related to its maintenance over time.

The reason why PP ducting is usually chosen for chemical fumes, acidic vapors, and other corrosive situations in industrial environments where polypropylene suits for the job. On the other hand, FRP Ducting is more suited for large-scale industrial ventilation and other applications that need customized structures.

Choosing the wrong material for your duct can result in various issues in the future.

What Is PP Ducting?

Definition of Polypropylene Ducting, PP Ducting

PP ducting refers to thermoplastics ducting which is made of polypropylene material. PP ducting is extensively applicable for transportation of corrosive gases, chemical vapors, and exhaust fumes.

PP ducting is ideal for applications that need chemical resistance, light weight, and easy manufacturing.

Applications of PP Ducting

  • Chemical process plants
  • Acid mist removal systems
  • Electroplating process
  • Pharmaceutical processing plant
  • Fume removal systems in laboratories
  • Chemical processing and storage facilities
  • Wet scrubber fume removal systems

Benefits of PP Ducting

  • Has a great resistance to many different acids, bases, and corrosive chemicals.
  • It is lighter than many other types of metal ducting systems.
  • Adaptable to both wet and corrosive exhaust conditions.
  • Is capable of being manufactured in different sizes and shapes.
  • Functions well with the appropriate PP scrubbers and removal systems.

However, polypropylene has temperature limitations.

What Is FRP Ducting?

FRP Ducting or Fibre Reinforced Plastic ducting is produced from a plastic resin which has been reinforced with glass fibers.

The blend of plastic and fiber results in a material which offers features such as corrosion resistance, strength, and design flexibility.

FRP Ducting is extensively used in ventilation systems which require handling of corrosive gas, fume or exhaust air.

Common Applications of FRP Ducting

  • Plants for chemical manufacture
  • Fertilizer production factories
  • Factories that deal with acids
  • Scrubbers in industries
  • Exhaust ventilation systems
  • Power generation plants and industries
  • Systems that extract corrosive gases

Advantages of FRP Ducting

  • High Strength/Weight ratio.
  • Applicable for large diameter ducts and custom designs.
  • Corrosion resistant if the resin system is right.
  • Can be designed for special structural and operational purposes.
  • Suitable for many industrial exhaust/ventilation systems.

FRP performance depends significantly on resin selection, laminate construction, reinforcement, fabrication quality, and operating conditions.

PP Ducting vs FRP Ducting: Key Differences

The following table compares PP and FRP ducting across important industrial selection parameters.

Parameter PP Ducting FRP Ducting
Material Polypropylene thermoplastic Glass fibre reinforced polymer
Construction Thermoplastic fabrication or welding Composite laminate construction
Chemical resistance Good for many corrosive chemicals Depends on resin and laminate
Temperature capability Limited by PP properties Depends on resin system and design
Weight Generally lightweight Lightweight relative to many metals
Mechanical strength Depends on thickness and fabrication Can be engineered for higher structural requirements
Large diameter applications Suitable with proper design Often suitable for large engineered duct systems
Custom fabrication Flexible thermoplastic fabrication Extensive composite design flexibility
Maintenance Depends on operating conditions Depends on laminate and operating conditions
Typical applications Chemical fumes, wet exhaust, corrosive ventilation Large industrial exhaust and corrosive ventilation

Important: Neither PP nor FRP ducting is universally superior. The correct material must be selected according to actual operating conditions and engineering requirements.

Which Ducting Is Better for Chemical Fume Extraction?

As regards chemical fume exhausts, either of PP and FRP ducting may be considered appropriate. This needs to take into consideration the chemicals used, their concentration levels, temperature conditions, and the overall design of the system.

Choose PP Ducting When:

  • Your application contains acids, alkalis, or corrosive vapors that can be used with polypropylene.
  • The exhaust system works within the proper temperature range for PP.
  • You need light weight thermoplastic ducting.
  • There is a process of chemical treatment, plating, or laboratory exhaust.
  • The ducting is connected to the compatible PP scrubber or exhaust system.

Choose FRP Ducting When:

  • The project needs to have big diameter industrial ducts.
  • The structural requirements will need engineered composite structures.
  • The exhaust system needs a resin system that can operate in its environment.
  • The project involves customized duct designs or industrial exhaust systems.
  • Mechanical design and supporting systems are key considerations in the project.

PP Ducting vs FRP Ducting: Chemical Resistance

Chemical resistance is one of the most critical criteria in the selection of industrial ducting.

PP is normally suitable for most acids and alkalis. FRP can also be highly resistant to corrosion with proper selection of the resin system and laminate.

Chemical resistance, however, is not dependent on the materials themselves.

The following must be taken into account:

  • Chemical composition
  • Chemical concentration
  • Temperature
  • Vapor composition
  • Duration of exposure
  • Formation of condensation in the ducting
  • Compatibility of resin/thermoplastic
  • Mechanical stresses and environment

In some cases, ducting for fumes of sulphuric acid will require a different material than that for other chemicals at high temperature.

 

Always verify chemical compatibility before finalising PP or FRP ducting for industrial applications.

How to Select the Right Industrial Ducting?

Selecting the right ducting involves more than comparing PP and FRP materials.

1.Identify the Composition of Exhaust Gases

Identify the type of chemicals being moved via the ducts.

Identify whether there is moisture, corrosive, particulate or condensable gases in the exhaust system.

 

2.Identify Operating Temperature

Identify the working temperature, highest temperature and possible temperature variations.

PP and FRP have different temperature ranges and the temperature range depends on the material properties and working conditions.

 

3.Identify Duct Size and Air Flow

The duct sizes are to be identified based on the required air flow, velocity and pressure drop.

Small duct sizes may result in high pressure drop and bad design will affect the extraction process.

 

4.Determine Mechanical Considerations

Consider the following:

  • Diameter of ductwork
  • Length of ductwork
  • Support spacing
  • External wind pressure in case of external installation
  • Vibration 
  • Thermal expansion
  • Details of flanges/ joints
  • Inspection / maintenance accessibility
5. Consider the Complete Extraction System

Industrial ducts must be chosen as part of the whole ventilation system.

Components of the system can include:

  • Industrial fume hood or exhaust port
  • PP/FRP ducting
  • Industrial blower
  • Scrubber or other pollution control equipment
  • Stack

System compatibility and performance must be considered throughout the whole system.

PP Ducting and FRP Ducting for Scrubber Systems

Both PP and FRP ducts can be installed in the system of an industrial scrubber.

PP ducts may be used when there are compatible corrosive fumes and polypropylene scrubbers in the system.

The use of FRP ducts can be appropriate for large exhaust systems that require engineered composite ductwork.

It all depends on the scrubber discharge conditions, exhaust temperature, chemicals, airflow, etc.

Explore related products:

Common Mistakes When Selecting PP or FRP Ducting

Industrial ducting selections that should be avoided:

  • Material selection solely based on cost.
  • Neglect of chemical concentration and temperature.
  • Misconception that all FRP resins have equal chemical resistance.
  • Assuming compatibility of PP with any acid/chemical.
  • Neglect of support for ducts and load.
  • Incorrect selection of duct diameter without calculating air flow and pressure loss.
  • Neglect of condensation and accumulation of liquid.
  • Wrong use of joints, flanges, and sealants.
  • Duct selection independent of blowers and scrubbers.

Properly engineered ducts ensure reliability and extraction of gases, thus reducing unnecessary maintenance.

Conclusion

Both PP Ducting and FRP Ducting have certain benefits that are highly useful in ventilation of industries and chemical fume extraction.

PP ducting is a good solution for many corrosive exhaust systems, which require thermoplastic material. FRP ducting would be a good option for those systems that need composite construction and customized designs along with large exhaust systems for industries.

The material of the ducts is the one which suits your chemical environment and mechanical requirements along with temperature and flow rate.

Plastic Fabricators produces industrial plastic and FRP products for the chemical process, ventilation and exhaust systems.

If you need customized ducting solutions, please provide us with details about the chemicals, operating temperature, diameter of ducts, airflow and installation.